Innovation Ecosystem

Bee vigilant forever

You can prevent the poisoning of bees, children and pets by halting the use of toxic chemicals on your lawn

Image created by Joanna Detz

Reprint this sign and put it on your lawn as a positive step to say no to toxic lawn chemicals.

By Richard Asinof
Posted 4/29/19
With the launch of “Bee Vigilant,” ecoRI News and ConvergenceRI created a collaborative partnership to give voice to consumers and citizens to help them create an engaged community in the digital world we live in, focused on promoting a positive way to promote an end to the sprinkler system of toxic chemicals on lawns in Rhode Island. One way that citizens can become involved is to take control of their own lives and lawns and become “Bee Vigilant.”
What kinds of outreach are needed to enlist landscaping companies to join with “Bee Vigilant?” Will the 11 colleges and universities in Rhode Island sign on to the effort to become “Bee Vigilant?” Would the R.I. General Assembly act to make the State House lawn “Bee Vigilant?” Will the R.I. Department of Health be supportive of this effort? What are the best products on the market to promote organic lawns? Will someone in Rhode Island publish that list? Will Save The Bay join onto the campaign and post the “Bee Vigilant” flags on its headquarters in Providence?
One of the missing ingredients in the effort to combat toxic lawn chemicals is a good database to capture what is happening: how many pounds of toxic lawn chemicals are released into Narragansett Bay and its tributaries each year? What are the correlations, if any, with the impact of nitrification of the Bay? How many pounds of toxic chemicals are contained in each lawn treatment for a typical lawn? What are the rates of miscarriage in Rhode Island that may be related to suspected exposure to toxic lawn chemicals? What is the content of pesticides and herbicides in mother’s milk in Rhode Island?
In the three years since this story was first published, with a question asking, “What is the content of toxins, including mercury, in fish and shellfish in Narragansett Bay?” new research has been conducted to answer that question, the beginning of a valuable conversation and convergence. That is a positive development.
New attention has begun to focus on the potential harmful effects of the persistence of PFAs in the environment – a class of chemicals that do not break down easily, earning them the nickname, “forever chemicals.” They are not only persistent in our waterways, they are persistent in our bodies, too. Research has correlated PFAs found in pregnant mothers and newborns with higher levels of childhood obesity.

PROVIDENCE – It is springtime in southern New England. In addition to all those bright colors of daffodils and tulips in bloom and buds on the maple trees emerging in a natural pointillist canvas, there are those annoying harbingers of an increasingly toxic landscape: yellow and white flags sprouting up, warning of toxic chemicals applied to lawns, with their alluring promise of a greener future but the reality of a more silent spring.

The lawn may be “greener” in color, but at what cost to the families, children and pets playing on those lawns? What about the irreparable harm caused in the poisoning of bees and other pollinators and beneficial creatures?

The facts are surprising and chilling, according the national advocacy group Beyond Pesticides.

The National Academy of Sciences estimates 50 percent of lifetime pesticide exposure occurs during the first five years of life.

A study published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute finds home and garden pesticide use can increase the risk of childhood leukemia by almost seven times.

Studies show low levels of exposure to lawn pesticides are linked to increased rates of miscarriage, and suppression of the nervous, endocrine and immune systems.

Exposure to home and garden pesticides can increase a child’s likelihood of developing asthma.

Studies link pesticides with hyperactivity, developmental delays, behavioral disorders and motor dysfunction.

Children aged 6-11 have higher levels of lawn chemicals in their blood than all other age categories. Studies have found that pesticides pass from mother to child through umbilical cord blood and breast milk.

What is green?
As with the difference between good taste and tasting good, a greener lawn isn’t necessarily a greener lifestyle; rather, it often serves as a sprinkler system for toxic chemicals.

As Pogo once warned us, we have met the enemy and he is us; our desire for a greener lawn often leads to our own self-dosing with toxins. All change begins on the inside, as Dr. Martin Luther King said. Being greener begins with personal choices in the way we lead our lives – and treat our lawns.

As detailed in the three companion articles [see links to stories below], there are many ways to have a healthy, greener lawn without resorting to toxic herbicides, pesticides and lawn treatments.

But, beyond taking that individual step forward, we need a way to celebrate and to share positive choices with friends, family and neighbors, and, in doing so, change the conversation and the practice.

One lawn at a time
Odds are, you or many of your neighbors are going to be susceptible to the lure of advertising, like the one in a recent circular from a popular Rhode Island discount store, which offers a well-known fertilizer product with a manufacturer’s rebate and a store gift card, in the urge to render lawns greener – and unwittingly more toxic.

In 2016, in an effort to increase consumer awareness about the use of pesticides and lawn fertilizers, ecoRI News and ConvergenceRI, to celebrate Earth Day on April 22, began sponsoring a “Bee Vigilant” campaign. Post these green flags on your lawn, on a tree or in a window, to help bring attention to the continued overuse of lawn poisons.

This campaign doesn’t require legislative action; it doesn’t cost you any money; you don’t have to register online to post a comment; you can be a Republican, a Democrat, an Independent, a Moderate or even a former Cool Moose party member.

The origins of the idea go back to July 2015, when Joanna Detz, co-founder of ecoRI News, and I were guests of Ted Nesi on WPRI’s “Executive Suite.” As we walked out of the studio after taping, we discussed ways in which our organizations might collaborate on a project: the idea of addressing pesticides on lawns was first mentioned.

What we hope the Bee Vigilant campaign does is create a new kind of engaged community in today’s very digital world. Neither ConvergenceRI nor ecoRI News can make any promises about what will happen if you plant one of these do-it-yourself flags in your lawn.

Will your lawn be healthier? We expect so. Toxic chemicals and fertilizers often degrade the soil, causing you and your lawn to be more dependent on more and more applications, according to organic lawn-care experts.

Will you enjoy your lawn more? We believe so.

Will you save money? Perhaps. Building your own compost pile is a lot cheaper than buying poison-laden fertilizers and pesticides. But investing in healthier, safer organic products to protect pollinators may cost a bit more upfront.

Will birds, bees, butterflies and beneficial insects thank you? Their renewed presence will speak volumes.

Why Bee Vigilant?
The numbers are scary and surprising. As a 2016 New York Times article reported, “The birds and the bees need help. Also, the butterflies, moths, wasps, beetles and bats.”

A recent report on the global assessment of the threats to pollinators warned that an increasing number of species are at risk of extinction, including 16 percent of vertebrates such as birds and bats, and at least 9 percent of bees and butterflies.

From a macroeconomic view, the global assessment talked about how pollinators, including some 20,000 species of wild bees, contribute to the growth of fruit, vegetables, nuts and flowering plants. It also noted that plants that depend on pollination make up some 35 percent of the global crop production volume, with a value estimated to be as much as $577 billion a year.

One of the noted bad actors in this drama is a class of insecticides known as neonicotinoids, or neonics for short. They are among the most widely used insecticides in the United States and worldwide. They are marketed by European chemical giants Syngenta and Bayer.

Neonics are a potent class of systemic pesticides introduced to agriculture in the 1990s. Products that contain this insecticide include Knockout Ready-To-Use Grub Killer, Ortho Bug B Gon and All-In-One Rose & Flower Care, among others, according to Beyond Pesticides.

Neonicotinoids have been linked by some studies to the decline in bees. The Maryland Legislature recently enacted a law, which became law without the governor’s signature, to ban their use by consumers beginning in 2018. Connecticut has also passed a similar law banning the use of neonics by consumers in 2016.

In Rhode Island, however, there has been pushback about enacting similar legislation. During a March 23, 2016, Senate Environment and Agricultural Committee hearing to discuss a bill that would ban or severely restrict the use of some neonicotinoids in Rhode Island, the continued use of the bug killer received endorsements from state officials, local farmers and scientists.

There is also still much that needs to be done, in terms of research and studies, to see, for example, the impact herbicide-resistant GMO crops — soy, cotton, rice, rapeseed (canola oil) and corn that dominate U.S. and global agricultural — are having on the environment. [The recent jury decision in California in March of this year to award Edwin Hardeman $80 million in damages, based on his claim that the herbicide RoundUp and its active ingredient glyphosate, caused his cancer, is considered a bellwether trial, with hundreds of cases against Bayer, which acquired Monsanto in 2018, now pending.]

Milkweed plants, which once thrived in North America, are in a precipitous decline, allegedly as a result of such agricultural practices. In return, the number of monarch butterflies, which lay their eggs on milkweed as they travel from their winter home in Mexico northward, have dwindled, so much so that some scientists are worried they could be extinct in 20 years, according to a 2016 article in Scientific Reports.

The problem, according to John Pleasants, an ecologist at Iowa State University, is that the United States has lost an estimated 1 billion milkweed plants since the 1990s, in large part because of herbicide spraying on cropland in the Midwest.

Efforts to reform global agricultural practices, independent research and the establish of “butterfly zones” are some long-term solutions worthy of investment.

In the meantime, Bee Vigilant offers a way for consumers to take action at the consumer level. The marketplace sometimes does listen to the voice of consumers; there’s a reason why the market for organic products grew 11 percent in 2015.

Richard Asinof is the editor and publisher of ConvergenceRI, on online weekly newsletter launched in September 2013.

Editor’s note: ecoRI News and ConvergenceRI have partnered to create a positive consumer awareness campaign to educate the public about alternatives to toxic lawn chemicals and insecticides.


No comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment

© | subscribe | contact us | report problem | About | Advertise

powered by creative circle media solutions

Join the conversation

Want to get ConvergenceRI
in your inbox every Monday?

Type of subscription (choose one):

We will contact you with subscription details.

Thank you for subscribing!

We will contact you shortly with subscription details.