Convergence RI logo
Mind and Body/Opinion

Critiquing capitalism, seeking empathy

In a tale as old as time, it’s the story of empathy and the need to belong to a community

Photo courtesy of Katy Linwood

Katy Linwood recently celebrated the 12th anniversary of her sobriety in her monthly column, “The Brighter Side,” in ConvergenceRI.

By Katy Linwood
Posted 2/23/26
The release of the files related to the investigation and prosecution of the late Jeffrey Epstein, a convicted child sex abuser, brings with it triggers — and the demands from survivors that all alleged perpetrators be held fully accountable for their criminal misdeeds. The files’ release also brings out the brutal reality of economic inequality in our country and the importance of belonging to a neighborhood.
How do we redefine the concepts of neighborhood and community in a state so severely divided by wealth and access to services, including health care? What does it mean to be poor, to run out of money, to be living out of your car, to be covered over by snow in a hospital parking lot, then to freeze to death — without being discovered for two weeks? What is the best way to ask for help when you have run out of money and you have no food?
I once resided in Montague Center, a rural town some 12 miles north of Amherst, where Route 63 heading north and Route 47 heading north came within a mere quarter-mile of intersecting. I lived on Union Street in what had once been a worker residence built for employees of the Montague Boot & Shoe factory. All the two-by-fours used in the house’s construction were made from chestnut, the cheapest lumber because of the blight.
When the February blizzard of 1978 struck, dumping more than two feet of snow, my housemates and I put on our cross-country skies and then traversed the town on skis, going as far west as we could to the town boundary defined by the Connecticut River. We then skiied back to our rented house, warming up besides our woodstove, cranking up the heat. That was a history of a blizzard from some 50 years ago.

PROVIDENCE —If capitalism has no haters, then I’m dead.

And, speaking of death, here's the hill upon which I will die: There is no ethical way to become a billionaire.

Capitalism is predicated upon the idea that individuals are in their position (socially, economically, etc.) because it is deserved. Cognitive dissonance is the grease that lubricates its mental wheel.

Capitalism tells us that the poor are that way because they deserve it —and that the wealthy are exceptional. And I call bullshit.

That mentality is an excuse for individuals to deliberately ignore our hard-wired need for community.

Humans are social creatures, and despite what billionaires might want you to believe, we depend on each other for survival.

Disconnecting from each other to the point where individuals feel entitled to possess extreme wealth while hunger runs rampant is diabolical. Ignoring the very real suffering of community members is dangerous.

Empathy is notably — mandatorily — absent under capitalism. Assets are the ultimate sign of success.

Accumulating wealth builds power and further encourages the delusion of individualistic exceptionalism. In late-stage capitalism, someone’s worth as a person is directly tied to their “net worth” (assets minus liabilities). How disgusting.

Without empathy, the door is wide open for exploitation and violence. The Epstein files are shocking to our collective consciousness, and all I can see is the thread of capitalism throughout. I’m surprised by the depravity, but I am unphased by the ultra-wealthy’s hypocrisy.

Prosperity is policy-based, in the sense that governmental policy gives people the ability to build wealth. When those policies are dismantled, the American Dream becomes smoke swirling just out of our grasp.

The affordability "lock-out" has arrived. The cost of daily goods and services are escalating while wages aren’t keeping up. Many of us are now aspiring to afford what used to be "standard." This is not inevitable; this is deliberate.

Public policies can help or harm us, and it’s a choice that policymakers are actively choosing. The state and federal government have the power to strengthen American families by equalizing the tax structure, making childcare more affordable, investing in education and job training, and subsidizing housing and health care.

But! Capitalism gives no incentive for the wealthy (powerful, politically influential) to move this forward. The goal is to accumulate more and more. Always more, no matter the cost — if the cost isn’t a financial one.

One huge disclaimer is that policies and historical injustices have created extreme racial divides across the spectrum. There is no way to critique America and American capitalism without loudly recognizing that — as well as recognizing the gender disparities.

Resources, power, and opportunity are distributed disproportionately —and that’s very much by design. The lottery of birth has a profound and perhaps permanent effect on how well someone will fare in life. Generational wealth and all the associated opportunities are not earned, nor is racism or sexism. Helpful and harmful forces that are completely out of our hands dictate so much of our destiny here in America, but capitalism can’t account for that.

Unsafe activities
When wealth building becomes impossible, it can encourage unsafe activities. As someone with addictive tendencies, mass normalization of gambling-like activities is something I am extremely wary of. The unpredictable nature of something like sports betting is a dopamine rush akin to using substances. I have been sober for 12 years now, and I will never try gambling because I know I’m predisposed to like it too much. I worry about people who haven’t yet reached sobriety, or those for whom addiction to gambling will give a swift kick in the teeth.

I know that when and if that happens, capitalists will tell them that it’s all their fault.

Katherine ‘Katy’ Linwood writes a monthly column on sobriety, “The Bright Side,” for ConvergenceRI. Connect with her on IG@katherine.linwood

 
 

 

© convergenceri.com | subscribe | contact us | report problem | About | Advertise

powered by creative circle media solutions

Join the conversation

Want to get ConvergenceRI
in your inbox every Monday?

Type of subscription (choose one):
Business
Individual

We will contact you with subscription details.

Thank you for subscribing!

We will contact you shortly with subscription details.